Raise the Rates is hosting a movie night on Friday, February 2nd, from 6-8pm. We will be screening I Daniel Blake and having break-out discussions about the stupid rules of welfare and the qualifications that make it impossible to get on welfare.
Because while we know that the rates need to be raised significantly, we also know the government drags their heels on increasing income assistance. In the meantime, there are so many rules and qualifications the ministry can change to make receiving assistance easier!
JOIN US for some snacks, a movie, and a conversation about how we can push back against the stupid rules of welfare.
When? Friday February 2nd 2018
What time? 6-8:30
Where? Carnegie Theatre, 401 Main St
Light refreshments and a place to vent will be provided!
Contact Kell, email@example.com for more info or to help out!
These are the reflections of our organizer, Kell, after CBC’s Food Bank Day. We hosted a pop-up rally that day to demand system change. This op-ed went out to several different media sites, and not a single one picked up. Guess it’s too hard to hear the mainstream media is failing justice movements…hmm…
The bright red band-aid shaped banner read “JUSTICE NOT CHARITY”. A dozen of us– activists, advocates, supporters of Raise the Rates– chanted and cheered outside of CBC’s Food Bank day for “justice not charity!” and “Raise the welfare rates now!” A class of grade 6 students, presumably coming for the open house tour of CBC hosted that day in conjunction with their food banks fundraiser, stand on the sidewalk and watch us, interested. I turn to them, and get them chanting with us “justice not charity!” A brave move on the part of their teacher (learning moments around every corner, on every sidewalk), I am asked to tell them a bit about what we are there to do.
And fair enough–are we some cruel money-hungry conservatives who hate food banks? Not in the slightest. In a short three minutes, I outline that food banks began as a temporary measure….35 years ago. A temporary measure to tide over the increasing number of people in poverty experiencing food insecurity. Yet, it’s 35 years later, and the need for food banks and number of people accessing them every year is on the rise. Why? Because government hasn’t raised welfare rates to anywhere near the poverty line, or built thousands of units of social housing a year like it used to. Because government refuses to raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour. Because, in short, the government continues to be as neglectful as it has. So we are here to push for a broader awareness that we need more than just charity: we need justice. We need a strong, inclusive, cross-ministerial poverty reduction plan. We need welfare rates to be raised significantly, and rent control, and a higher minimum wage. Solutions to poverty that we have been advocating for 35 years.
The students nodded along, seemingly capable of grasping that if there are people drowning in a river, you need to pull the people out and also fix the hole in the bridge that put them there in the first place. Even while food banks may pull some people out of the river, relying on generosity will not change legislation. Charity, in fact, only increases the cycle of dependency and saviourism that keep people in poverty.
What we need, on days like CBC’s Food Bank Day, is advocacy. We need a letter writing station to MLAs, we need loud protests and louder conversations that push the mainstream into understanding causes of poverty–and its solutions.
That afternoon, I was slated for a 3 minute and 30 second interview on CBC’s live show. I figured, hey, if a class of thirty 11 year olds can understand justice not charity, in 3 minutes, surely some of the listeners will have light bulbs go off. Too bad the producer’s notes said “don’t get too political–we don’t have time”. Too bad I was ushered off stage after 2 minutes. Too bad CBC is incapable of truly supporting anti-poverty efforts; believing instead that whiskey-and-cheese donation packages deserve more airtime. I like whiskey as much as the next person, but I like justice (ending homelessness, increasing income assistance/minimum wage/old age pension, creating an affordable childcare plan, implementing and respecting UNDRIP…) infinitely more.
It is not any more ‘political’ for me to state that you won’t end homelessness unless you raise welfare rates, than it is to say the days get darker in December. It is not a ‘radical’ thought to believe every human deserves a life of dignity, safe and affordable shelter, the ability to purchase culturally relevant food. I don’t know when those ideas became radical.
I am here for more than generosity. I am here for deep and actual change. CBC–it’s about time you were too.
For immediate release–
November 1st 2017
VANCOUVER, COAST SALISH TERRITORIES
While the government has implemented the election promise of raising income assistance by $100, Raise the Rates has launched their 6th Annual Welfare Food Challenge to highlight that this is not enough. The point of the challenge is to raise public awareness on the inhumanely low welfare rates. Raise the Rates challenges the public to live on just $19/week for food.
“Last year, the challenge was set at $18. Only $1 more in a week for food, even with the increase. This is because of the rising cost of rent, lack of rent control, cost of living”, says Kell Gerlings, organizer with Raise the Rates. “We know it’s not enough, the minister knows it is not enough, so what is stopping the government from acting to end poverty, not legislate it further?”
At the launch, just outside of the Nofrills on East Hastings St, low-income speakers spoke on the difficulties of living on only $19/week. “This is what I have to live on,” says Erica Grant, a community member in the Downtown Eastside, pointing to the basket of “welfare diet” food, “ramen noodles. I know it’s not healthy. But I have no choice. It’s just shameful the way we are treated.”
“We do this challenge so that more and more people can understand the impossible situation that people on welfare face. It’s not about ‘just budget better’–it is the fact that people are being kept in poverty. And if the government really wants to show their commitment to reducing or ending poverty, then rates need to be raised,” says Gerlings. “Food banks and free meals won’t solve poverty. Poverty is political, it is a policy choice.”
The Welfare Food Challenge runs until Tuesday November 7th. While the challenge only lasts a week, people on welfare are actively living this challenge with no choice to quit, every day. “This is why we need welfare rates to be increased. The government should not use consultation to stall on doing the actual things that need to be done. We have the solutions. Raise the rates.”
pictures by Carnegie Community Action Project: https://www.flickr.com/photos/carnegieaction/24243547688/in/album-72157662153476518/
We have launched our 2017 Welfare Food Challenge over at https://welfarefoodchallenge.org/ !
Let’s be real: While the new government is taking steps, these steps are much too small and much too slow to begin to tackle the depth of poverty that people on welfare have to fight against, every day. Even with a $100 raise to income assistance, our food challenge is only $1 more in the week than last year. This means that we are challenging YOU to budget and survive on only $19/week for food.
We are running the Welfare Food Challenge this year from Wednesday November 1st to Tuesday November 7th. The aim of the Challenge is raise public awareness about the poverty of people on welfare and the need for change. To help publicize the Challenge, we hope you will document and publicize your experiences. This could include:
Please sign up here: https://welfarefoodchallenge.org/join/
And if you can’t participate this year, please get a colleague, friend, family member or acquaintance to sign up—most importantly, start the conversation.
Start the conversation because so many people think we no longer need to continue it.
$710 is not enough.
Raise the Rates is fighting to end poverty and homelessness. If you have any questions or would like to participate, please contact Kell Gerlings at firstname.lastname@example.org or 778.871.0141
Why $19 for a Week’s food?
|Rent (realistic rent for an SRO)*||$548|
|Room damage deposit||$20|
|Bus fare ($6 compass card, 2.20/trip, or 10 trips at 2.85) (to look for work)||$28|
|Cell phone (to look for work)||$25|
|Total of all non-food expenditures||$631|
|What’s left for food||$79|
$79/m * 12 months = $948 a year
$948/a year/365 days = ~$2.60 a day
~$2.60 a day * 7 days = $18.2, rounded up to $19
No money for clothes, a coffee, haircuts, or any social life or treats.
Note on SRO rent:
The most recent report coming from the Carnegie Community Action Project shows that the average lowest rent in SRO hotels in the DTES is $548. This contrasts with the Provincial government’s shelter allowance portion of welfare of $375 a month.
(Reference: Carnegie Community Action Project, Out of Control: The Rate of Change and Rents in the Downtown Eastside, page 8 of 24 http://www.carnegieaction.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/CCAP-SRO-HOTEL-REPORT-2016.pdf)
On August 15th, a small group of Raise the Rates organizers and volunteers headed to Minister Shane Simpson’s downtown Vancouver office to give him our demands. This is our confirming letter.
To Minister Shane Simpson;
Hello! Raise the Rates coalition here. We are writing to confirm the demands we brought forward to our meeting on Tuesday August 15th, where we spoke about the necessity of raising welfare rates to at least the market basket measure of $1680 (for Vancouver area), how we can’t end homelessness without raising rates, how impossible it is to get PWD, how people are losing their lives in poverty, and how a more equal society benefits everyone.
Raise the Rates is a coalition of people in poverty, organizers, advocates, faith groups, unions, community groups and organizations. We have spent many years demanding the government to commit to ending poverty. Two weeks ago, we asked you, what kind of legacy does the NDP want to have? Do you want to end poverty, legislate it further (which it will be with rates kept at the level they are now, $710/single person), or reduce it? We gave you a list of arbitrary barriers to accessing welfare that you could remove with an order in council. These barriers stem from the 50% diversion rate in welfare offices, which, if this policy was abolished, more people would be able to access the support they need.
We are sending along this letter asking you to respond to our demands:
One of our group members said to you, “We know you are inheriting a huge mess, but people are losing their lives”. We understand the mess the Liberals made, and the devastating effects of their policies. We call upon you, Minister Simpson and your fellow ministers, assistants, deputy ministers, parliamentary secretaries, everyone in office, to push forward bold ideas and an unshakeable commitment to ending poverty. We will continue to change the minds and hearts of the public to come to understand that $610, $710 is not enough to live on, and that a more equal society benefits all. What you must do now is support these ideas publicly, and set an example of what a just, reconciliation-focused BC could actually look like.
In Struggle and Solidarity,
Raise the Rates
In early June, Raise the Rates contributed to the Federal Consultation on creating a poverty reduction plan. We doubt this will have much impact– consultations feel very removed from any actual change. However, it’s about time the federal government was talking about a poverty reduction plan (though it should really be a poverty ABOLISHMENT plan). If you ever wanted a comprehensive idea on what we stand for, read on…
Dear Honorable Jean Yves Duclos,
This is the response of the BC Raise the Rates coalition to your request for input into how a National Anti-Poverty Strategy should look.
Who is Raise the Rates? Raise the Rates includes 22 member groups such as the Carnegie Community Action Project, Positive Living, Streams of Justice, BC Teachers Federation, Downtown Eastside Neighbourhood House, Gordon Neighbourhood House. Our members also include low income individuals. We have been working since 2006. We sponsor the Welfare Food Challenge every year, where we ask people to eat only what they can buy with what a person on welfare has for food money. We also hold actions designed to pressure governments to raise welfare rates, restore bus passes to people with disabilities, etc.
Article 25 of the UN Declaration of Human Rights: We believe Canada should comply with the Article 25 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights: “ Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.” We believe that these rights should be enshrined in Canadian law so they are actually enforceable.
We support the development of a comprehensive national poverty reduction strategy that is grounded in human rights and has strong targets and timelines. It should be legislated and adequately funded. This strategy should provide strong policy responses to address poverty.
Raising welfare rates: Raise the Rates has focused on trying to get the BC government to increase current welfare rates which have been frozen at $610 a month for a single person for over a decade. This means that single people who pay the average rent of $548/month for a single room occupancy hotel room in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside have only $2 a day left for food and everything else. http://www.carnegieaction.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/CCAP-SRO-HOTEL-REPORT-2016.pdf
We need to restore national standards for welfare: Prior to 1996 the federal government shared the cost of welfare payments 50/50 with provinces providing the provinces complied with 4 rules that guaranteed basic economic human rights:
When the Liberal government abolished the Canada Assistance Plan in 1996, provinces lost half of the money they spent on welfare and low income people lost these rights. Provinces began either cutting or not indexing welfare payments until, now, they are completely inadequate and people who rely on welfare have an extremely hard time subsisting. This is about the time that homelessness in Canada started becoming a major problem. Before 1996 welfare provided enough money that people in need could access it and have enough to pay rent.
Therefore, Raise the Rates is calling on the federal government to again require national standards for welfare and contribute to provinces’ welfare expenses.
Two other national standards should be added to the four above:
Welfare amounts and access: Raise the Rates is calling on welfare to be paid at Market Basket level which would be about $15oo a month for a single person without disabilities. Provinces should also be forbidden from enacting measures that restrict access to people in need such as BC’s 5 week wait for assistance when you first apply, and the requirement that you prove that you’ve worked for 2 years prior to receiving assistance.
Minimum wage: A huge part of ending poverty is increasing the minimum wage. It should be $15 an hour now. While this is mostly in provincial jurisdiction, the federal government could enact it for federal jurisdiction and provide incentives for provinces to follow suit.
Housing costs are causing poverty: The federal government needs to allocate billions of dollars to build social housing that low income people can afford. In BC we need at least 10,000 units per year. Housing must be seen as a human right, not a commodity and governments must act to get a huge portion of housing out of the market like it is in places like Vienna and Hong Kong.
Childcare: Support for $10 a day or free quality childcare should also be a right of Canadians and would help many mothers escape poverty, although we believe that if single mothers want to stay home and raise their children income assistance should provide enough for them to do that.
Employment Insurance: Unemployment Insurance should be restored to all people who are unemployed, not a mere 40 or so percent, and rates should be increased, especially for people who have low wages.
End poor bashing. The federal government should take a leading role in countering discrimination, stereotyping and poor bashing of people who are poor. For example, the government shouldn’t just say it wants to help the middle class and people who want to be middle class. People who are poor are human too and there is no shame in not having a lot of money. The Canadian Human Rights Act should be amended to prohibit discrimination based on social condition including low income.
Poverty of Indigenous peoples: Land should be restored to Indigenous peoples. The theft of land has been proven again and again as the source of harm and poverty in Indigenous communities. The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People needs to ratified and implemented immediately, and the federal government needs to uphold the rights it has granted Indigenous communities through land and title immediately. All resource and land development on unceded Indigenous lands needs to be returned, and Indigenous economies need to be encouraged to flourish. In the meantime, the basic human right to an adequate standard of living should be implemented immediately for all Indigenous people–clean drinking water, the right to speak Indigenous languages, raise their children, and live free from discrimination.
Tax the rich. Studies by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives have shown that it’s cheaper to reduce than to maintain poverty. But there will be some up-front costs that should be paid for by increasing taxes on the rich and corporations, considering all the tax breaks and benefits that they receive. More studies show that inequality is associated with shorter life expectancies for people at all income levels but especially low income people. So taxing the rich can not only provide money for needed programs but also provide more equality and longer lives.
Thank you for looking at our recommendations
Kell Gerlings, organizer Raise the Rates
Jean Swanson, organizer Raise the Rates
If you are outraged by the games the BC Libs are playing with welfare rates and poor people’s lives….
If you are sick of the status quo, frozen welfare rates, homelessness, poor-bashing…
If you want to see change happen…
then JOIN US on MONDAY JUNE 26th at 7PM at Grandview Cavalry Baptist Church (1803 East 1st Ave) for our annual Thank You and What’s Next?! event. We will be sharing stories, desserts, and brainstorming for new ideas, fresh voices, and more energy in our campaign to raise the rates!
If you’ve never been to a raise the rates meeting…make it to this one! please RSVP to email@example.com so we know how many desserts to make!